| Date | Location | Result | |
| Oct 25, 2009 | Indianapolis, Ind. | Indianapolis 3, Maryville 1 | Box score |
| Oct 23, 2009 | Indianapolis, Ind. | Missouri S&T 1, Indianapolis 0 | Box score |
| Oct 18, 2009 | Springfield, MO | Drury University 2, Indianapolis 0 | Box score |
| Oct 16, 2009 | Kansas City, MO | Indianapolis 2, Rockhurst 1 (OT) | Box score |
| Oct 11, 2009 | Indianapolis, Ind. | Indianapolis 2, Quincy 1 (OT) | Box score |
| Oct 09, 2009 | Indianapolis, Ind. | Indianapolis 3, Illinois-Springfield 1 | Box score |
| Oct 4, 2009 | Romeoville, IL | Lewis 1, Indianapolis 0 (OT) | Box score |
| Oct 02, 2009 | UWP Somers, Wis. | UW-Parkside 6, Indianapolis 2 | Box score |
| Sep 27, 2009 | Rensselaer, IN | Indianapolis 2, Saint Joseph's (IN) 0 | Box score |
| Sep 20, 2009 | Indianapolis, Ind. | Northern Kentucky 2, Indianapolis 1 | Box score |
| Sep 18, 2009 | Indianapolis, Ind. | Bellarmine 3, Indianapolis 2 | Box score |
| Sep 13, 2009 | Owensboro, KY | Indianapolis 3, Kentucky Wesleyan 1 | Box score |
| Sep 11, 2009 | Evansville, IN | Southern Indiana 4, Indianapolis 2 | Box score |
| Sep 06, 2009 | Indianapolis, Ind. | Missouri-St. Louis 0, Indianapolis 0 (2OT) | Box score |
| Sep 03, 2009 | Columbus, Ohio | Indianapolis 2, Ohio Dominican 1 | Box score |
| Aug 30, 2009 | Jackson, Tenn. | Indianapolis 4, Lambuth 2 | Box score |
| Aug 28, 2009 | Memphis, TN | Indianapolis 1, Christian Brothers 1 (2OT) | Box score |